Photography takes an instant out of time, altering life by holding it still." - Dorothea Lange

Friday, February 28, 2014

Starving child in southern Sudan - Kevin Carter

© NY Times 
In 1993, South African Kevin Carter was working as photojournalist in the Sudan when he shot this incredibly moving and controversial photo of a starving child trying to reach a nearby food center. He subsequently sold the photo to the New York Times, and it would be printed in newspapers all over the world. He would eventually win the Pulitzer Prize for feature photography because of this image. The image would become a metaphor for the famine that was gripping much of Africa.

Early in his career Carter worked for the Johannesburg Star, bent on exposing the brutality of apartheid. In 1993 he went to Sudan to report on the effects the famine had on the people of this small African country.[1]

There are conflicting accounts of how Carter got the photo and he was criticized by some of his colleges for partially staging the image. He would later go on to say, "I was appalled at what they were doing. I was appalled at what I was doing. But then people started talking about those pictures... then I felt that maybe my actions hadn't been at all bad. Being a witness to something this horrible wasn't necessarily such a bad thing to do."[2]


It is a significant image to be sure. For me, the image brings up a very real moral questions when it comes to reporting the news. In cases like this are journalists simply there to report what they see or are they morally obligated to intervene? One could argue that the image brought worldwide attention to a situation that had largely been ignored up to that point. Many people would be moved to act because of how that image made them feel. It is a true testament of the power of the image.

On the other hand, was carter’s obligation as a journalist outweighed by his obligation as a human being?  Where do we draw that line? History is replete with such examples of those who saw fit to simply record what they saw, and not interfere. Are they right or are they wrong? I really don’t know. I can really see both sides of this issue.

As long as the darker side of humanity is present and there are those whose job it is to record such things, this question will continue.

A few months after the publication of the image Carter committed suicide. He was apparently struggling with depression and coping with the recent death of a close friend and colleague. He was 33 years old.


Gavrilo Princip in his Cell - Unknown

Gavrilo Princip photo, retrieved from newstrick.com

The degree which one individual can change history is often quite relative.  As human beings we have some power to change many things in our own little corner of the world. Still fewer of us have the ability to significantly impact the world on a larger scale. We can even change our own future is we believe we can. All that being said, there are only a few who can claim to have changed the history of the world in a very significant and profoundly impactful way.

No one person’s actions, has had more of a profound impact on the history of world in the 20th century than one Gavrilo Princip, and most people don’t even know his name or who he is.

On April 28, 1914 Princip assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria and his wife, Sophie, Duchess of Hohenberg, on the northern end of the Latin Bridge in Sarajevo. This act set in motion events that not only ignited the First World War, but it still has a profound effect on the world today.

Princip was a disgruntled and disenchanted young Bosnian. He like many other young Bosnians, was angered by the annexation and occupation of Bosnia and Herzegovina by the Austro-Hungarian Empire, so he decided to take radical actions.

Later when he was arrested, this expressionless photo was taken of Princip by one of his Jailers.  The vacant look seems to be in direct contrast to the world wide misery his actions caused.

His actions helped light the fuse to an already volatile situation between the major powers in Europe at the time.  

Four years later when the war was over the world was a profoundly different place.

Besides the tens of millions of casualties, the devastation, suffering and misery the so called Great War brought about, this is a short list of the more lasting legacies of the war:

The Influenza Pandemic of 1918-19
The Treaty of Versailles, World War II and the rise of Nazism
The inception of global communism and the fall of the Russian empire
The fall of the Ottoman Empire
The fall of the Hapsburg Empire
The rise of the United Sates as a global power
The decline of the British Empire
The redrawing of the maps of Europe, Russia and the Middle East
And Universal suffrage - Just to name a few 

For those who still doubt that we are still living with the legacy of that war, consider that there are still parts of France were people cannot live because of the enormous amount of un-exploded ordnance that is still present there prevents it.
In 2010 Germany finally made the last of its war reparations payments to France.


One angry young man with a gun and a bomb singlehandedly re-wrote the history of the world, and assured those who came after would live in a drastically different one. He no doubt never fully realized the consequences of his actions. 

Thursday, February 27, 2014

Lee Harvey Oswald and his Mannlicher-Carcano - Marina Oswald Porter

Donald Uhrbrock/Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image
At 12: 30 pm Friday November 22nd President John F Kennedy was shot and killed by an assassin while his open motorcade drove through the streets of Dallas Texas.

Later that same day Lee Harvey Oswald was arrested for the murder of a Dallas police officer. He was charged with the assassination of Kennedy and the murder of officer Tippit later that night.

As fate would have it, Oswald would never face a jury for these crimes. Two days later while being transported to another jail in Dallas he was shot and killed by Dallas night club owner Jack Ruby.
In 1964 the Warren commission concluded that Oswald acted alone. This image, which was taken by Oswald’s wife in the spring of 1963, was a key piece of evidence linking Oswald to the assassination. It would prove to be one of the most significant events in the United States in the latter half of the 20th century.

The death of Kennedy was a watershed event in American society. It signaled the end of the prosperous 50’s and the beginning of the turbulent 60's.

In the 50 years since the assassination a whole slew of conspiracy theories have cropped up around this particular event. Everyone from the phone company, to communists, the CIA to organized crime figures have been implicated in the murder of Kennedy at one time or another. According to a Gallup poll from November of 2013, 61% of Americans still believe that someone other than Oswald killed the president on that fateful day in Dallas. In other words, they believe it was a conspiracy.

This photograph is at the heart of many of the conspiracies. Even though many experts have concluded that the image is real, there are those who have found inconsistencies within the photo. The shadows are not right they claim. They site one thing or another in the photo is a tell in their opinion.

As a historian and photographer I love the duality of perception that such images can create in the minds of people. How can two different people look upon the same image and see two very different things? Our minds, our hearts, our life experiences, and our biases skew our perspective in many ways, but no more than examples like this.

Our history reveals much about us as a society. How we see ourselves our government and those around us goes a long way to explain how each of us see that history.

So long as there is a vacuum of information surrounding the assassination of John F Kennedy, humans will fill it with things they think makes sense, and this image will continue to be a big part that process.


What does the image say to you?

The Migrant Mother – Dorothea Lange

This image is available from the United States Library of Congress's Prints and Photographs division under the digital ID fsa.8b29516

As the Great Depression gripped the nation some of the most influential American documentary photographers came into their own. Dorothea Lange was one of these pioneers of photojournalism. A fiercely independent woman, she with little more than her camera and a beat up car gave the Great Depression a human face.

Her most iconic image was the 1936 photo called Migrant Mother. More than any other image, this photo has come to be the illustration of that era.  There is barely a textbook or webpage about this dark time in American history, which does not contain a copy of this image.  The image is of Florence Owens Thompson. It is part of a series of photos Lange took of Thompson and her Children. Lange spent a month documenting the struggles of migrant workers in California while working for the Resettlement Administration that was part of FDR's National Recovery Administration.

I would consider it a classic example of American Portraiture. All you need to know about the human side of Great Depression can be summed up in this simple yet profound image.

This image is significant because not only did it serve to define the great Depression by its incredible and human narrative, it set the stage for those photographers who would follow in the decades to come.


When you see a contemporary photo of a homeless person or any image that tells a story of human struggle; odds are the photographer who took it was influenced by the stunning work of Lange and her contemporaries. They came to define the art of photojournalism as we know it today.